The Illusion of Pure Reality: Nietzsche, Derrida, and the Case for Metaphorical Truth

I care about reality. AI art Introduction In a clip titled I Don’t Care About Jordan Peterson’s Metaphorical Truth , Matt Dillahunty, former host of The Atheist Experience , delivers a candid reflection on his encounter with Jordan Peterson. At one point, Dillahunty declares: “I don't care about metaphorical truths at all. I care about reality.” What seems like a straightforward appeal to common sense is, on closer inspection, laden with philosophical assumptions. Dillahunty’s statement not only distances him from Peterson’s symbolic interpretations of religion, but also inadvertently invites scrutiny from thinkers such as Friedrich Nietzsche, George Lakoff & Mark Johnson, and Jacques Derrida. Their theories of language and meaning challenge the sharp divide Dillahunty posits between metaphor and reality, and reveal the fragility of this opposition. Metaphorical Truth and Its Discontents Jordan Peterson has often suggested that biblical narratives, while not literally f...